Critics

by "bmccune" <bmccune(at)ix.netcom.com>

 Date:  Mon, 12 Jan 1998 06:47:31 -0600
 To:  "Critique" <hwg-critique(at)hwg.org>
  todo: View Thread, Original

Hello All,

        This is just a one time posting and shall not do it again I promise,
just have a little insight to say that I and maybe some others do not
understand nor feel is correct.

        I have enjoyed and I think learned a little more from all tha have
given input on my site but have also managed to see a flaw in the way things
can be critiqued.

        In short as possible this is what I have gotten from here, public
and in private and from the Web Page Form itself.

        "Your Page is very good, see no problems"  (IE 4.0)
        "I cannot read a thing on it, all is jumbled"  (Netscape 2.? forgot)
        "Most all I see starts right on the left border but content is good"
(Netscape)
        "Not bad but think the Banner is to much Mentioning of Dragon Works
maybe just Dragon works at the top would be better, do have most starting on
the left, also think you should make your table letters bigger" (Netscape)
        "When the curso as you said is on the tables I do not see anything,
its not working"
        "Relative verses non-relative links, hate openning alot of pages"
        "Like the way you keep the main page and open up others to your
other links"
        "The banner is very well done but feel it is to far to the right"

Ok this is just a few of the postings private and public but can you begin
to see the differences. When I 1st got a few I rushed to try to change
things, when I did I got a message saying I like this (had already took it
out).

I am using IE4.0, others have looked at the site with IE 4.0 No problems,
Netscape below 4 did say problems, Comni??? Said better and so on....

Point is what some say is wrong and bad is not, what others say is good is
not, what is not liked by one is by another so what do you change, what IS
the standard one is suppose to follow??

Again a 1 timer and will not do again I promise, any responses will not be
posted here but to that party as I now it is not correct for in here.

Thanks,
Ben

HTML: hwg-critique mailing list archives, maintained by Webmaster @ IWA