Re: Please compare 2 versions of same site

I like the original version much better.  The redesigned version is, in my
opinion, not professional enough.   I don't want to see words spinning
across the page and photos of her daughter (bad photo, BTW).  I want to know
what she's going to do for me.

I'd rework some  things on the original version. ..  clean up the link
graphics and drop shadow her photo and lighten it and code the images.

I only looked at the home page, but that's all most of your visitors will
bother with anyway.

W.
-----Original Message-----
From: Maelynn <maelynn(at)citynet.net>


>OK. I just finished a site for a local real estate agent.
>She sketched out how she wanted her site to look.
>So I did it just as she had asked.
>However, I designed another, more friendly site.
>
>Why did I feel so compelled to redesign the first site?
>
>Maybe you can tell me.
>Please check out both sites (both are only 6 or 7 pages)
>and let me know which I should suggest she use and why.
>She may very well not want me to take any artistic license with it but I
>felt I had to. I just don't like it the way she wanted it.
>If my version isn't better, please feel free to tell me so.
>
>Her version:   http://www.hdhomes.com/hite
>Redo:   http://www.hdhomes.com/hite2
>
>Thanks in advance...
>
>Maelynn Cheung
>Online Production Coordinator
>The Herald-Dispatch Online
>http://www.hdonline.com

HTML: hwg-critique mailing list archives, maintained by Webmaster @ IWA