Re: Gabocorp watch out. LOL

Personally, when I ask for a critique I think *every* reply is valid and
worthwhile.  Even those that just say "it sucks."  This is because if
someone on the list sees a site and they immediately think "it sucks" or
"just another typical...etc" the chances are someone else surfing the 'net
will also have the same reaction.  Sure, saying it sucks doesnt help much
in solving any problems and it doesnt offer any constructive comments, but
it lets you know what reaction people might have to your site.  I ask for a
critique not only to receive html tips but also to receive personal
comments.  This might include "it sucks" or whatever else.  I want to know
if someone thinks it sucks and has nothing else to say about it because
this might be the reaction a client has. 

thats all,
phil.

Perhaps we need a "critiques-only(at)hwg.org" list and a separate
"any-comments@hwg-org" list?

--------------------------------------------------------------
At 09:09 AM 2/5/99 +1100, you wrote:
>Have I gone to sleep and woken up in another world? Has this list been
>turned into the lets-think-positive list? The
>lets-all-use-positive-reinforcement-so-we-have-no-connection-to-reality
>list? I mean all this is very constructive, but let's not have an absence of
>truth in an effort be nice. I'd much rather have an atmosphere were the
>occassional gibe is taken without recourse to wounded pride and pointless
>posts about rudeness. Rudeness, really. Have you been out in the real world
>lately? If not, I'm afraid you'll find it a bit more rude than "it is a bad
>example of".
>
>And if anybody wants to start on about rules etc, could they please first
>check the lengths of their sigs
>
>- michael a
>

HTML: hwg-critique mailing list archives, maintained by Webmaster @ IWA