Re: protecting images

by David Jones <dvjones(at)ksbe.edu>

 Date:  Thu, 17 Oct 2002 09:33:24 -1000
 To:  hwg-techniques(at)hwg.org
 In-Reply-To:  master
  todo: View Thread, Original
On 17 Oct 2002, at 4:53, Bob Laurence wrote:

> actually you can use digimarc to track them online if they
> are downloaded. It imbeds a watermark in the image to
> track them. www.digimarc.com

I've used Digimarc. Their watermarks aren't very hard to 
remove.

I've wonder if you couldn't adapt the "image tracing" 
technology (used by many drawing programs to turn 
photos into vector graphics) to produce a unique 
signature identifying how the image looks (shapes, 
colors, composition, etc). Then if you think someone is 
violating your copyright, you could run a similar process 
on the suspected image and compare the results.

> Or you can use eyemageIIE from www.proporta.com to embed a
> water marc or send an encrypted message within the image
> and password protect it.

Don't know about that one, but I can't imagine how 
"password protecting" the image would help. I use 
several image editors that completely ignore any non-
graphic info in the file, and don't include it in the file 
when you do a Save As. And tying it to some 
proprietary viewer just guarantees that visitors won't be 
able to see your graphic (and in my case, would never 
come back to your page!).

> You can't stop the downloading of the images but you can
> track those that use them again online.

Not very effectively AFAIK. As always, you have to 
decide whether the actual value of maintaining tight 
control over use of your images is worth the expense of 
such products (including the time needed to use them 
and the time needed to track and prosecute violations).

David
dvjones(at)ksbe.edu

> sincerely,
> Bob Laurence
> Re-Data.com LLC
> "We may not know it all, but we know the web"
> 
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: "Ryan Ositis" <ryan(at)yetiarts.com>
> To: "marg cameron" <knmc2cm(at)yahoo.ca>
> Cc: <hwg-techniques(at)hwg.org>
> Sent: Wednesday, October 16, 2002 6:17 PM
> Subject: Re: protecting images
> 
> : Marg,
> :
> : While this issue occasionally gets asked, I'm afraid
> that the answer is : no. If it is on the web, anyone can
> download it and do what ever they : want. That's just the
> nature of the Web. : : If unauthorized use of the photos
> is a serious and overriding concern, : perhaps you should
> rethink putting them online. : : HTH! : : -Ryan : : marg
> cameron wrote: : : > is there a way I can protect the
> images so that no one : > can download these private
> photos for unauthorized : > use? : > thanks : > Marg
> Cameron : > Alzheimer Society of Toronto : >
> www.alzheimertoronto.org : > : >
> __________________________________________________________
> _______ _____ : > Post your free ad now!
> http://personals.yahoo.ca : : -- : Ryan Ositis : Yeti Arts
> Web Development : (206) 229-7947 : ryan(at)yetiarts.com : :
> 
> 
> 


 

HWG hwg-techniques mailing list archives, maintained by Webmasters @ IWA

This page is part of a preserved archive of archives.hwg.org. The site is no longer active and its content is not maintained. For enquiries about this archive, write to archive(at)iwanet.org.