Re: 1st site critique...

Andy,

Just remember, this critique is worth exactly what you paid for it ;-)

Win98, IE 4.x, 56K modem, plenty of colors, 1024x768 and other various
resolutions

HOMEPAGE:
I'm in the anti-splash page camp (even though the opening page of my site is
a semi-splash page).  I don't like getting a page that does nothing but send
me to another page to navigate the site.  Especially if I have no idea what
the site's about (and I don't).  That being said, I love the look.  At
640x480, there's about an inch of downward scroll.

HARBOUR:
Frames!  Ack!  I can't bookmark the individual pages of your site.  If I do
the right click > Create Shortcut thing, I lose your navigation.  If I click
on the Harbour logo in the navbar, I can't get back to your little
definitions page.

NAVBAR:
I think you have spaces in your navbar code after the Contact Us and In The
News graphics and before their closing </A> tags.

GENERAL:
I'm pretty dense, but I don't have a really good sense of what it is you
guys do after viewing your site, or how I pay you to do it for me.  I don't
think you get enough value from the framed design to bother using it.  I'd
go with a table (but then I'm horribly biased).  I think the background,
color scheme and overall look are great.

HTH -
Mike Eovino
Webmaster
Estes Express Lines
http://www.estes-express.com (please critique)




-----Original Message-----
From: acwahl(at)inil.com <acwahl(at)inil.com>
To: hwg-critique(at)hwg.org <hwg-critique(at)hwg.org>
Date: Wednesday, July 07, 1999 10:28 AM
Subject: 1st site critique...


>
>
>Hi.
>
>First time poster to this list- Looking for some honest eval from the
>throbbing mass of <goodness> that is the hwg.
>
>I'm in the process of creating my first site. There's plenty of cleanup and
>finishing work to do, and some of the content needs to be completed- but
>would like to get a critique on the overall look & feel, consistency,
>cross-browser compatibility- stuff like that. Jeez. I'm nervous, I really
>am. Be nice and gentle, please?
>
>Tanks yoos
>
>andy w.
>
>site is at www.harbouronline.com
>
>
>
>

HTML: hwg-critique mailing list archives, maintained by Webmaster @ IWA